Is Germany's Model Broken?

A Turning Point for German Industry

Germany’s economy is facing an unprecedented crisis that has shaken its core industrial sectors and threatened its political stability. Industry experts are witnessing economic challenges on a scale unlike any in recent memory. Key sectors such as automotive, chemicals, and engineering are simultaneously in decline, creating immense pressure on companies.

• The economic slowdown in Germany has been mounting gradually, with Europe’s largest economy showing limited growth since late 2021.
• Industrial production, excluding construction, has decreased by 16% since its peak in 2017. Corporate investment has declined in most recent quarters, and forecasts for GDP growth are bleak, with the IMF predicting minimal expansion next year.

Germany now ranks among the slowest-growing advanced economies, alongside Italy.

Manufacturing & Political Woes

In the manufacturing sector, Germany’s historical powerhouse, the situation appears especially dire. Volkswagen has suggested potential plant closures within Germany for the first time in its history, while renowned firms like Thyssenkrupp and Continental are grappling with existential challenges that threaten thousands of jobs. Even the 225-year-old shipbuilder Meyer Werft narrowly avoided bankruptcy with a government bailout.

• Economists are calling this downturn in industrial production the most severe since World War II, signaling a fundamental shift in Germany’s industrial landscape.
• Amidst economic turbulence, Germany’s political environment has become increasingly volatile. Chancellor Olaf Scholz’s coalition of social democrats, greens, and liberals struggles to maintain unity, sparking speculation of a possible collapse and snap elections.

The political void left by a weakened center has fueled the rise of populist movements, with far-right and far-left parties gaining significant traction. This shift raises concerns about the future of Germany’s stable, consensus-driven political system and its impact on the broader EU.

High Costs, Aging Infrastructure and China

Germany’s economic challenges are compounded by structural issues. High energy costs, elevated corporate taxes, and labor expenses make the environment less favorable for businesses. A shortage of skilled workers and deteriorating infrastructure, the result of decades of under-investment, exacerbate the situation. As German consumers grow increasingly cautious, the savings rate has surged, further slowing economic momentum.

• Germany’s economic woes are amplified by changing dynamics with China. Once a reliable export market, China has evolved into a formidable competitor.
• German carmakers, for example, are now competing with China’s rapidly growing electric vehicle (EV) industry. For years, German automotive companies thrived in the Chinese market, but today, homegrown Chinese brands such as BYD and Nio are capturing market share with competitively priced, technologically advanced electric cars.
• Since 2016, Germany’s auto production has declined by over a quarter, with tens of thousands of jobs lost and more at risk.
• As the automotive industry shifts to EVs, suppliers face even greater challenges. Electric vehicles require fewer parts than traditional combustion engines, impacting engineering firms specializing in complex automotive components. Leading suppliers are investing billions in new technologies to adapt, but this shift has led to significant job cuts.

Germany’s second-largest automotive supplier, ZF Friedrichshafen, is planning extensive workforce reductions as it transitions to new technologies, underscoring the challenges of a rapidly transforming sector.

A Fragile Government Response

Initially, Chancellor Scholz and his administration downplayed the crisis, hoping for a quick economic revival driven by green technology investments. But as economic data worsened, the government implemented modest reforms to stimulate growth, including incentives for corporate investment and energy subsidies for certain industries. Internal coalition conflicts, however, have marred these efforts, raising doubts about the administration’s ability to address Germany’s underlying economic issues.

• The economic and political challenges have created an opportunity for Friedrich Merz, leader of the opposition Christian Democrats (CDU), who has positioned himself as a potential savior of the German economy.
• Merz has outlined a new “Agenda 2030,” aimed at reducing bureaucratic red tape, lowering corporate taxes, and improving industrial competitiveness.
• Inspired by former Chancellor Gerhard Schröder’s transformative “Agenda 2010” reforms, Merz’s agenda seeks to modernize the economy and restore Germany’s position as a leading industrial power.

Despite the daunting challenges, some believe Germany retains the potential for recovery. With a strong labor market and sound public finances, the country is still better positioned than in past economic downturns. Germany’s expertise in sectors like green technology, industrial automation, and health care offers promising avenues for growth.

Disclaimer

Please note that Benchmark does not produce investment advice in any form. Our articles are not research reports and are not intended to serve as the basis for any investment decision. All investments involve risk and the past performance of a security or financial product does not guarantee future returns. Investors have to conduct their own research before conducting any transaction. There is always the risk of losing parts or all of your money when you invest in securities or other financial products.

Credits

Photo by Stephan Widua / Unsplash.